top of page

The Original Acrylic Enva Clear Boat
vs.
Polycarbonate Knockoff China Copies

Acrylic Boat vs.China Polycarbonate Boat

Poly-carbonate boats are less rigid than acrylic boats due to their lower modulus of elasticity and higher ductility (significant plastic deformation), which allows them to flex more under load. While this flexibility enhances impact resistance, benefiting products such as windshields and other impact protective products, it can lead to excessive deformation, stressing seams and joints, and potentially causing hull failure through fatigue, de-bonding, or cracking. For poly-carbonate boats to be viable, they often require additional structural supports or careful seam design to mitigate flexing-related issues.

 

See video and photos shared by a China Knockoff boat end user. The materials, lack of structural integrity hull design  is evident. The vessel is held together with nuts, bolts and silicone bonding. The end user of this China Limelight boat has asked us for assistance in determining how to repair the keel parting from the hull. The screws have dislodged from the threads and fallen out, while the keel is held together by the silicone that is leaking sea water.

Carafino Designed Clear Boats

Acrylic’s greater rigidity, UV resistance, and lower thermal expansion make it better suited for maintaining structural integrity and seam stability in marine environments, particularly for transparent or clear-bottom boats used in snorkeling or touring applications. For our bluewater boats, acrylic is the only material we use and with the added Mil-Spec superior rigidity, scratch resistance, and UV stability. We choose acrylic over polycarbonate for its longer service life and enhanced sealing properties. 

Material Facts

Acrylic, while less impact-resistant and prone to cracking under extreme force like collisions, is more resistant to fatigue from flexing, making it ideal for hull designs requiring consistent rigidity. Its stiffness suits applications like glass-bottom or clear boats for snorkeling and tours, where a stable viewing platform is essential. Acrylic’s rigidity also prevents oil-canning and excessive panel flexing, maintaining hull integrity and reducing seam stress, unlike flexible polycarbonate hulls often found in lower-quality boats.

bottom of page